United States: Division over Mideast Poilcy
Washington, Apr. 15 2002 (VOA News) -- As
the Bush Administration gets involved in the Middle East conflict,
its ranks are sharply divided on policy between moderates who
support mediation and the Powell trip and hawks who back Israel's
military action and oppose negotiations at this stage.
A group
of conservatives, or neo-conservatives as they are generally
known, signed a letter to President Bush asking him to remain
steadfast in his support of Israel amid a sea of tyranny,
intolerance and hatred. "You have declared war on international
terrorism," says the letter. "Israel is fighting
the same war."
The President
has not answered, says one of the signers, Gary Schmitt, executive
director of the Project for the New American Century. But
then his response is not expected.
What has
arrived are various replies from lesser figures in the Bush
Administration, some cheering the letter, others not. "Typically,
what you get is a lot of feedback from people within the administration,
commenting, complaining or supporting your efforts because
in typical fashion most administrations have divided opinions
about most issues," Mr. Schmitt said. "It keeps
the debate alive, and it also helps shape the debate among
reporters and people on the hill."
Some of
the approving replies came from neo-conservatives in the administration
who would undoubtedly have signed the letter if they had been
outside government. Press reports have expressed surprise
at the ability of the neo-cons to get policy making positions,
since some of them have been quite critical of the President.
One of
the letter signers, Marshall Whittman, told the Washington
Post, perhaps partly tongue-in-cheek, that an entire neo-con
cell had infiltrated the White House despite its reputation
for tight control. He is amazed.
U.S. Secretary
of State Colin Powell is the number one rival of the neo-cons,
but Mr. Schmitt concedes he is presently on top. "Once
the President committed to sending Secretary of State Powell
to the region, then it is almost inevitable that the secretary
is going to wind up driving the actual content of the trip,"
he said. "So I am not surprised that Secretary Powell's
views on the Middle East the mediation effort have come to
dominate and define how his trip is taking place."
This can
quickly change, adds Mr. Schmitt, if the Powell trip fails.
Then the President might think better of his efforts at mediation
and return to full support of Israel's military policy. But
he says neo-cons remain somewhat skeptical of the President's
inclinations.
For good
reason, says John Voll of the Center for Muslim-Christian
Understanding at Georgetown University. Since there is no
consensus on policy, the President fails to lead.
"Therefore,
the Powell trip is simply an affirmation that the United States
needs to pay attention," he said. "But I do not
get the impression that President Bush has given significant
instructions to Powell as opposed to having the secretary
of state go simply to see what the situation is."
Professor
Voll says the neo-conservative view has gained prominence
because of its stark simplicity. That resonates with a President
who says in the war on terrorism you are either for us or
against us.
"The
neo-conservatives are so convinced of the absolute ability
of the United States to be the sole superpower that they are
willing to say we do not even need our European allies to
get things done that we want to have done," he said.
"So it is this blindness to the interconnected nature
of global politics that I think is causing some real problems."
Blind
or not, the neo-cons keep coming, a high State Department
official told the New Yorker magazine. "These guys are
relentless," he said. "Resistance is futile."
They have
the advantage of a coherent, if narrow view, writes the New
Yorker. Secretary Powell tends to think case by case. The
conservatives have outflanked him, says the magazine, by thinking
big. They envision a new world order, that given the U.S.
interventions they have in mind, will not be all that orderly.
-- Ed
Warner - Voice of America in Washington
--
Reprinted with the permission of Voice of America
-- To respond to this story or post a follow up e-mail
editor@insnews.org
|