Russian
Upper House Passes New Media Restrictions
Gregory Feifer
- Radio
Free Europe
Moscow, 13 November 2002 (RFE/RL) -- Russia's upper
house of parliament today overwhelmingly approved
amendments to the country's media law that would put
restrictions on news coverage of antiterrorism operations.
Federation
Council members voted 145 to one to pass the new curbs
despite protests by free-speech advocates who say
the measures could be used to stifle any criticism
of the Kremlin.
Federation
Council spokesman Valerii Manilov said ahead of the
vote that the amendments would "increase the
effectiveness of the fight against terror and consolidate
our society." "The amendments pending our
approval today draw lines, set limits for today's
informational disorder, and bring about responsibility,
not only for journalists who should adequately cover
events like the recent tragedy [hostage crisis in
Moscow] and the fight against terrorism in general,
but also for the authorities and law-enforcement agencies.
So it is a mutual responsibility," Manilov said.
The
amendments would bar the media from distributing information
that would hinder counterterrorism operations or reveal
tactics used in such operations or information about
people involved in them.
The
measures would also prohibit the publication or broadcast
of "propaganda or justification of extremist
activity."
The
legislation was drawn up before last month's crisis
in which Chechen rebels took more than 750 hostages
in a Moscow theater. At least 128 hostages died during,
or later as a result of, a controversial rescue operation.
Officials
condemned media coverage of the events, which featured
stepped-up news broadcasting and live mobile-telephone
conversations with hostages and hostage takers.
Duma
Foreign Affairs Committee chief Dmitrii Rogozin told
RFE/RL that the media could have jeopardized the operation.
"When I saw on NTV television a group of special-operations
troops move toward the 'Nord-Ost' [theater] building
at five [o'clock] in the morning [during the rescue
operation], I can imagine that the terrorists could
have seen the same thing, which is entirely not right,"
Rogozin said.
Liberal
politicians and journalists' advocates meanwhile condemned
the new regulations.
Yabloko
Party head Grigorii Yavlinskii wrote an open letter
to Federation Council Speaker Sergei Mironov criticizing
the legislation. "This formulation extends not
only to terrorists but to all who allow themselves
to criticize the authorities' actions," he wrote.
Oleg
Panfilov, director of the Center for Journalism in
Extreme Situations, said the hostage crisis triggered
official concern that they would not be able to, as
he said, distort the truth. "The authorities
adopted changes to the law so quickly and began to
talk about the necessity of controlling the press
in such crisis situations because they probably became
very frightened that journalists can publish information
they produced themselves and that contradicts official
versions," Panfilov said.
The
government was accused of heavy-handed meddling during
the hostage crisis. On the last day of the standoff,
the Media Ministry abruptly ordered Moscow's Channel
3 off the air for 15 hours for allegedly airing possible
escape routes for the hostage takers.
The
government also threatened to shut down Internet sites
and reprimanded a number of newspapers.
The
Russian media have seen increasing restrictions since
President Vladimir Putin took office in 2000, including
the takeover by state-connected organizations of some
outlets controlled by Kremlin opposition figures.
Putin,
in Brussels on 11 November, lashed out at a French
reporter, startling his hosts with crude and angry
language in response to a question about government
policy on Chechnya.
Putin
must now sign the new amendments for them to become
law.
Copyright (c) 2002. RFE/RL, Inc. Reprinted with
the permission of Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty,
1201 Connecticut Ave., N.W. Washington DC 20036. www.rferl.org
--
To respond to this story or post a follow up e-mail
editor@insnews.org |