Kuwait:
Many Still Await Word On Fate Of Loved Ones
Ron Synovitz - Radio Free Europe
Hawali,
Kuwait; 20 February 2003 (RFE/RL) -- Rajaa Marzouk
begins crying when she talks about what happened to
her son, Ahmed al-Fuhaid, in early 1991 during the
Iraqi occupation of Kuwait.
Al-Fuhaid
was a 19-year-old student when he was arrested by
Iraqi troops and charged with being a member of the
Kuwaiti resistance. Iraqi documents captured after
the 1991 Gulf War prove that her son was transferred
to a prison in Basra, Iraq, when the Iraqi Army retreated
from Kuwait.
Iraq has
so far failed to disclose information about more than
600 missing Kuwaitis, despite Baghdad's obligations
under a series of UN Security Council resolutions
to release all prisoners like al-Fuhaid, or to account
for those who may have died in detention.
If he is
still alive somewhere in an Iraqi prison, Marzouk's
son would now be 31 years old. Marzouk, like many
other Kuwaitis angered by Baghdad's noncompliance
on the issue, says she thinks a U.S.-led war to oust
Iraqi leader Saddam Hussein is her last chance to
learn the fate of her son and other missing prisoners.
"We
are not afraid of the war. If the war will bring back
our missing loved ones, or let us know about what
has happened to them, it is all right. We welcome
the war," she said. "Saddam didn't do anything
good to this country. He hasn't done anything good
for his neighbors. I am praying to God that we will
get rid of Saddam because our beloved ones were collected
from the streets and the schools, from anywhere, without
committing any crimes. All we want now is to know
something about the fate of our beloved ones. We cannot
accept it when Saddam says that he doesn't know anything
about them."
Baghdad
claims that all Kuwaiti prisoners transferred to Iraqi
prisons during the occupation of Kuwait escaped during
the failed Iraqi Shi'ite uprising against Saddam's
regime. That uprising began in early 1991 when a U.S.-led
international coalition stormed the country.
Baghdad
also says that all of its records about those prisoners
were destroyed in the Shi'ite riots. And it says the
burial sites of those who died before the uprising
are inaccessible because they have since been covered
by land mines.
But one
of Kuwait's chief negotiators with Iraq, Muhammad
al-Haddad, accuses Iraq of lying and says Saddam's
regime is being uncooperative on the issue.
"All
the Kuwaiti people are, in fact, hurting because of
this," he said. "They think the Iraqi government,
the Iraqi regime, the Iraqi authorities are not honest
in dealing with all issues -- not only the POWs ,
[but] all issues, [including disarmament]. They maneuver
around. They do not say things clearly and frankly.
They are not even honest with themselves."
Al-Haddad
is a board member of Kuwait's National Committee for
Missing Persons and Prisoner-of-War Affairs. He thinks
some of the 600 missing Kuwaiti prisoners are still
alive in Iraqi prisons. He believes Saddam has been
holding them for use as bargaining chips in the future.
Kuwait, he said, will never stop trying to discover
the truth about what happened to them. "The issue
of the POWs is a crucial issue for us. We care about
it, and we will follow it up until we come to an adequate
ending for it."
Abdul Hamid
al-Attar said he feels certain Iraq is lying about
the missing prisoners because he, himself, had been
repeatedly lied to about the detention of his son.
It was in September 1990, when al-Attar's son -- also
a teenage student at the time -- was arrested in Kuwait
City by Iraqi troops on grounds that he was a member
of the Kuwaiti resistance. Despite repeated denials
about the arrest by the occupying Iraqi troops, al-Attar
managed in early 1991 to find the prison in Kuwait
where his son was being held.
Al-Attar
says he had a heated argument with the Iraqi prison
guards when they denied any knowledge about his son.
It was then, he says, that his son heard his voice
and shouted for help from his cell.
Al-Attar
says an Iraqi guard pulled out a pistol, fired it
at his foot and told him the next bullet would be
in his head unless he left immediately. Al-Attar says
that was the last time he heard his son's voice.
In 1996,
Baghdad admitted that al-Attar's son was taken into
Iraq by retreating Iraqi troops. His case is one of
126 that Iraq has replied to, albeit inconclusively,
when presented with evidence found in Iraqi documents
captured by the Kuwaiti government. But Baghdad continues
to deny having information about the whereabouts of
al-Attar's son. There has been no answer from Baghdad
on the other 479 cases.
That has
left al-Attar puzzled about the lack of pressure from
the international community for Iraq to comply with
its UN obligations on missing prisoners. "Why
is the question of the POWs not included in [UN] Resolution
[1441] by itself as an item?" he asked. "The
United Nations and European countries, and everyone,
what they are talking about is that Saddam Hussein
must cooperate with the [UN weapons] inspectors [and]
must give up his weapons of mass destruction. But
they are not urging him [enough] to solve the problems
with Kuwait."
Kuwaiti
negotiator al-Haddad said the answer is clear: "The
disarmament is something different from the POWs [issue].
That is why it is getting the whole interest and the
whole attention of the world compared to the POWs.
But I am not going to say that we are alone. We have
had some help from all of the Arab heads of state,
from China, Japan, North Korea, South Korea, even
from Russia and definitely the United States. But
they cannot do much about it. They cannot say if you
do not release these 605 [people], we are going to
war with you. But they can say that about the weapons
[of mass destruction]."
Still,
al-Haddad says it is frustrating for Kuwaitis to see
the issue of the missing prisoners treated as a lower
priority than Iraq's disarmament obligations. He says
Kuwaitis want to see Iraq comply with all of the surrender
terms it agreed to when the Gulf War ended.
"We
have [UN Security Council] resolutions that concern
the POWs. We have [UN Resolution] 1284, and we have
[Resolution] 686 [and Resolution] 687. All [are] resolutions
related to the POWs. The Iraqis, for them, this is
not their priority. They know they are obligated.
They have a commitment. They have to implement all
these resolutions," al-Haddad said.
Investigations
by independent nongovernmental organizations such
as Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch confirm
that more than 600 Kuwaitis who were detained by the
Iraqis in 1990 and 1991 have remained unaccounted
for since the withdrawal of Iraqi forces from Kuwait.
A report
in August 2000 by the special rapporteur for the UN
High Commissioner for Human Rights stated that Saddam's
regime has the ability to clarify the fate or whereabouts
of those still missing. That UN report said what appears
to be lacking is the "necessary political will"
on the part of Iraqi authorities to cooperate.
The International
Committee of the Red Cross, which was supposed to
be granted access to prisoners as a term of Iraq's
1991 surrender, also has complained repeatedly about
Iraq's noncompliance.
And in
December 2001, the UN General Assembly called on Hussein's
government to cooperate with a special commission
that had been set up to establish the whereabouts
of several hundred missing persons. The Tripartite
Commission is made up of Iraq, Kuwait, and Saudi Arabia,
and its meetings are monitored by officials from the
United States and Britain.
Al-Haddad
said he has met with Iraqi officials 62 times during
the last 12 years to discuss the fate of the prisoners.
But he said those talks have not resulted in any breakthroughs,
and that all he has heard from the Iraqi side are
excuses.
At the
most recent meeting, conducted in Amman last weekend,
al-Haddad said one of his Iraqi counterparts claimed
to have forgotten important documents he had earlier
promised to deliver. That round of talks ended with
the head of the Kuwaiti delegation, Ibrahim al-Shaheen,
accusing Baghdad of failing, once again, to cooperate.
The Iraqi delegates refused to comment.
The next
meeting of the Tripartite Commission is scheduled
for 2 March. Al-Haddad emphasized that Kuwaitis' anger
about the missing prisoners is directed solely at
Saddam Hussein's regime -- and not at ordinary Iraqi
citizens. "Historically speaking, Kuwait is a
good friend of the Iraqi people, as the Iraqi people
are good friends to us. We have been living in peace
with the Iraqi people. We love the Iraqi people, as
the Iraqi people love us. We share the same problem.
We share the problem of this regime [of Saddam Hussein].
This regime is giving us a hard time, as Saddam is
giving the Iraqi people a hard time. We still have
a problem that is not yet solved with the Iraqi regime
-- the POWs issue. We look forward to having help
from the Iraqi people, and if they help us, we definitely
will never forget this. God willing, the end of this
regime will arrive and there will be new hope for
all Iraqis to live in peace and in democracy,"
he said.
Like many
relatives of those still missing, al-Haddad concluded
that regime change in Baghdad may be the last hope
for discovering the truth about the fate of loved
ones.
Copyright
(c) 2002. RFE/RL, Inc. Reprinted with the permission
of Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty, 1201 Connecticut
Ave., N.W. Washington DC 20036. www.rferl.org
--
To respond to this story or post a follow up e-mail
editor@insnews.org
|